Hello,
Your router's connection status LED indicates, that your router is connected to 3G, but has no data session established.
Most common reason for such issue is misconfigured APN. Please make sure that correct APN is indeed entered in "Network -> Mobile" menu (even though your SIM cards are from same provider, they might need different APN, if they have different services assigned to them (e.g. one standard SIM and another with Public IP address)).
Please also try using this SIM card in any other device, e.g. smart phone and check both if it is working and what APN is being used.