Hello Justin
Thanks for contacting TELTONIKA | Crowd-support forum.
I recommend you keep Encryption method as WPA2-PSK and modify only Cipher from Force TKIP and CCMP (AES) to Force CCMP (AES), then click on 'SAVE & APPLY' button in order to overcome that for iPhone and MacBooks.
In this manner, your wireless would still running properly without any issues.
Should you need any additional information please let us know.
Best Regards,